We're Back Pizza Reviews, Ratings & Menu | 106 Boston Post Rd, Orange CT

General Info

If you’re wandering down Boston Post Rd in Orange, Connecticut, We're Back Pizza at 106 Boston Post Rd C is a spot that instantly feels like home. From the moment you walk in-or even if you just swing by for curbside pickup-the vibe is casual, friendly, and unmistakably pizza-centered. Families, groups of friends, or even solo diners will find something to love here, especially since the restaurant is good for kids and makes everyone feel welcome.

The menu at We're Back Pizza is straightforward but satisfying, focusing on the classics done right. Their crust is perfectly balanced: thin enough to stay crispy but sturdy enough to hold generous toppings. While they don’t skimp on the cheese, the flavors are fresh and never overwhelming. Whether you’re grabbing a classic pepperoni or exploring specialty pies, each bite carries that homemade, oven-fired taste that keeps people coming back. For those busy evenings, takeout is seamless, and the curbside pickup makes it incredibly convenient for a quick dinner without losing any quality.

Reviews often mention the efficiency of the staff and the consistency of the pizza, which says a lot about the quality standards at this location. Paying is easy too, as they accept credit cards, making transactions quick and hassle-free. The atmosphere is unpretentious and kid-friendly, which makes it a go-to spot for family dinners. Kids can enjoy their personal slices while parents settle in with a hearty pie, all without feeling rushed or crowded.

Even beyond pizza, the menu’s variety ensures there’s something for everyone. Whether it’s a late-night craving or a casual dinner, We're Back Pizza delivers both flavor and convenience. You can tell the team behind the counter takes pride in every pie, maintaining consistency that draws in regulars and first-timers alike. With its location being easily accessible and the staff always ready to accommodate, this spot has become a small but beloved part of the local dining scene.

Overall, for anyone looking for a welcoming pizza spot in Orange, CT, We're Back Pizza blends convenience, quality, and a friendly dining experience. From curbside pickup to family-friendly dinners, it’s a place where the menu, service, and atmosphere come together naturally, making each visit a satisfying one.

What customers say?

“ We’re back’s large pies are 18” in diameter while most places’ are 16”. Were back’s medium is 16” so right off the rip, you get more bang for your buck AND they have way better prices than mostly everybody else too. It was roughly $42 for a large cheese and a medium pepperoni with bacon. Just to put that in context: my favorite place charges that for one large two topping. Super crispy crust with no flop. My only regret is that I forgot to ask for garlic on the medium but I’ll just rectify that the next time we order from here. Post 2: really good, reasonably priced calzones too. ”

- Albert “No Onions” Ruggiero -

“ Finally found a place that sells by the slice in West Haven. Its nice, clean and cozy. Many different selection of pizza you can imagine. Taste amazing, my favorite one, Beef Stroganoff pizza. I will come back to try the other slices. ”

- Lee Ly (This is Lee) -

“ The stuffed meat pizza was great! The cheese, thin-crust pizza was great! The cinnamon sugar dough balls were great! And the owner was very friendly and told me the origin of the name of the place. Will be back! ”

- Melinda Schultz -

“ I love pizza. I can eat it every day. We’re Back far exceeded my expectations. Their pizza is the best I ever had. You will notice that other pizza shops rely on toppings for flavor. Their dough and sauce alone is just incredible. No words to describe their Pizza!! They will be a National success in my opinion!! ”

- daniel haslam -

“ We're Back pizza is everything you ever dreamed about amazing pizza. It will make your eyes roll back its so delicious. I dont need to go further into New Haven because this place blows them out of the water. 5 stars. Best quality and ingredients and like nobody else in the area. Not even close. ”

- D D (D) -

“ We’re Back Pizza definitely lived up to the name because I’ll for sure be back again. The pizza was fresh, hot, and full of flavor from the first bite to the last. The crust was perfectly cooked (not too thick, not too thin), the sauce had great flavor, and the toppings were generous without being overwhelming. The staff was friendly and the service was quick, which made the experience even better. You can tell they take pride in what they do. If you’re looking for a solid pizza spot that delivers quality and consistency, We’re Back Pizza is worth checking out ”

- Slim Henny -

“ Finding good pizza is tough, but finding great gluten-free pizza is even harder. We’re Back Pizza delivers on both! Their gluten-free pies come as 10” pizzas, and they don’t skimp on flavor—you can make any of their pizzas gluten-free. Michael, the owner, was wonderful and the service was phenomenal. My sister is already planning to order nine pizzas for my nephew’s party because it’s nearly impossible to choose from all the tasty options! ”

- Francis Madrigal -

“ Omg if you haven't tried We're Back then you are missing the boat! We enjoyed lunch here (and honestly grabbed a few more slices for dinner) and the options are endless! The pizza was delicious, cooked to perfection and the cannolis were just as amazing! Highly recommend the chicken alfredo and the crew. I loved the fact that they serve slices. Super friendly staff and love the history of Mike and his wife Christine coming back to CT! Can't wait to come back. Thanks Mike for the warm welcome! ”

- Dave & Teresa Patrick -

Welcome to We're Back Pizza

General Info

We're Back Pizza menu

We're Back Pizza Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places